asphalt vs metal

4 Noticeable Differences of Asphalt vs. Metal Roofing. Which is Better?

It's time for you to get a roof replacement, and you have two options: asphalt vs. metal roofing. While asphalt roofing is the most accepted and used roofing system in the world, metal roofing has undergone tremendous improvement in material, design, and color.

Below we analyze comparisons between asphalt vs. metal roofing in cost, lifespan, warranties, and maintenance.

If you need help making heads or tails of the choice between asphalt roofing and metal roofing, the Indianapolis roof repair experts at Bryant Roofing can help. Give us a call at 317-342-4050 or email us at  service@bryantroofs.com

Variety of Styles

There are a lot of choices to make when deciding between roof tile types and roofing styles. Will standard asphalt roof shingles get the job done, or do you prefer metal shingles? Here are some items to consider as we make the roofing material types. They include:

  • Color Variety
  • Roof Material Weight
  • Material Cost
  • Climate Adaptability

No matter the type of roof you ultimately decide upon, our Indianapolis roof replacement experts are here to help you make the best roof replacement that fits your homes roofing needs


Consider Budget

A budget is an important thing to consider before the start of any project, and it is important to consider both roofing materials based on the cost implications both in the short and long run. An asphalt roof will cost roughly half of the cost of metal roofing both in purchase and installation.

Metal roofing requires more labor and skill to install compared to an asphalt roof replacement. Homeowners running on a tight budget might go for asphalt, which will be more affordable, while if you have extra money, you can install metal roofing and forget it for the next 50 years.

The lifespan of roofing material is critical for those who have invested in a forever home and probably not that important to the others. An asphalt roof lifespan if maintained well is somewhere between 20 and 30 years while a metal roofing will be over 50 years, all other factors held constant. A benefit of metal roofing is that it will have double the lifespan of asphalt roofing and, therefore, by far more durable.

Roof Warranties Make a Difference

Roofing materials come with warranties like any other product in the market. It is very important to consider the warranty of both materials before deciding which one to take. No one wants to have problems with their roof a few months after installing them. Asphalt roofing generally comes with a warranty of 30 years with a probability of an enhanced warranty of up to 50 years.

On the other hand, metal roofing comes with a 30-year warranty with no room for an enhanced warranty. An asphalt roofing has a better warranty, extending beyond its lifespan if you get the enhanced warranty.

metal roof

Roof Maintenance

Maintenance of roofs is the periodic inspection of all the areas of a roof that are vulnerable to a problem. Metal roofing virtually requires no maintenance throughout its lifespan, while homeowners should maintain asphalt once a year. This factor gives metal roofing an edge because maintenance is time-consuming and leads to additional costs. Many homeowners would need a roof that they install and forget.

Asphalt vs. Metal Roofing? Metal Roofing Wins.

Lifespan and maintenance give the metal roofing an edge over asphalt roofing. Metal roofing will probably not even need a warranty due to the nature of the material, and the initial cost will be compensated with the lack of residual maintenance cost. In asphalt roofing material, cost-effectiveness at the start diminishes as you start to incur maintenance costs.

Many homeowners are ready to part with a few extra dollars to avoid the nuisance of regular maintenance. However, it is imperative to decide what a homeowner will need without availing of the above fact and leaving them to choose, but I will go for metal roofing all the time.

Get Your 24-Hour Estimate

Work with Bryant Roofing on your next claim, and you’ll see why our clients call us “responsive, fast, and professional.”
5808 Bertha Street – Indianapolis, IN